Literature Reviews - 2025

Comprehensive Review of They Called Us Enemy by George Takei

Introduction

They Called Us Enemy is a poignant and powerful graphic memoir by George Takei, co-written with Justin Eisinger and Steven Scott, and illustrated by Harmony Becker. The memoir recounts Takei’s childhood experiences in Japanese American internment camps during World War II, providing a deeply personal yet historically rich narrative. Through compelling storytelling and expressive illustrations, the book sheds light on a dark chapter in American history while drawing parallels to contemporary issues of discrimination and injustice.

Narrative and Themes

Takei’s story is framed around his own reflections and public speeches, seamlessly transitioning between his childhood memories and his adult understanding of those experiences. The memoir effectively juxtaposes the innocence of childhood with the harsh realities of systemic racism and government-sanctioned oppression. His parents, particularly his father, emerge as central figures who navigate the injustice of internment while trying to preserve a sense of normalcy for their children.

Thematically, They Called Us Enemy explores the resilience of the human spirit, the cost of prejudice, and the long-term effects of injustice on individuals and communities. The book also highlights the sacrifices made by Japanese American families, including those who served in the military while their loved ones remained imprisoned. Takei’s later activism and commitment to justice are framed as direct consequences of his experiences, reinforcing the importance of historical memory and civic engagement.

Art and Visual Storytelling

Harmony Becker’s illustrations play a crucial role in the memoir’s emotional impact. The black-and-white artwork, with its clean lines and expressive characters, effectively conveys both the warmth of family bonds and the stark reality of life behind barbed wire. Becker’s attention to detail ensures that each character is visually distinct, enhancing the reader’s connection to their struggles and triumphs.

The panel layouts are straightforward and easy to follow, making the book accessible even to readers unfamiliar with graphic novels. The manga-inspired elements, such as exaggerated facial expressions and dynamic action lines, add depth to the storytelling, reinforcing both the emotional highs and lows of Takei’s journey.

Historical Context and Relevance

One of the memoir’s greatest strengths is its integration of historical and legal context. It does more than narrate Takei’s personal story—it educates readers about the broader implications of Executive Order 9066, the loyalty questionnaires, and the legal battles surrounding internment. The book highlights figures like Fred Korematsu and Wayne Collins, underscoring the resistance and advocacy that arose in response to injustice.

Importantly, They Called Us Enemy draws parallels between past and present, warning against the recurrence of xenophobic policies. The book’s discussion of the Trump administration’s travel ban and the treatment of immigrant detainees at the U.S.-Mexico border reinforces the notion that history can repeat itself if lessons are not learned.

Critical Reception and Impact

The memoir has been widely praised for its emotional depth, historical accuracy, and accessibility. Many reviewers have compared it to March, the graphic memoir by Congressman John Lewis, as both works use personal narratives to illuminate significant civil rights struggles. Takei’s ability to translate complex historical events into a deeply personal and engaging story ensures that They Called Us Enemy resonates with a broad audience, from young adult readers to educators and historians.

Some critiques of the book mention occasional moments where the dialogue feels overly scripted, particularly in its educational segments. However, these instances do not detract from the overall effectiveness of the narrative. If anything, they reinforce the book’s role as both a memoir and an educational tool.

Conclusion

They Called Us Enemy is an essential read that combines powerful storytelling with historical education. George Takei’s deeply personal account of his family’s internment, paired with Harmony Becker’s evocative illustrations, creates an unforgettable reading experience. The memoir not only preserves the memory of a dark period in American history but also serves as a call to action against contemporary injustices.